Why Content Marketing Is Very Sustainable – Via the Long Tail of the Internet

Nicholas Kosar Marketing, Technology 8 Comments

On January 6, social media consultant Mark Schaefer published a fascinating article titled “Why Content Marketing Is Not a Sustainable Strategy” in which he stated that the supply of content marketing is outstripping the demand for that product.

With the ever-increasing numbers of blogs, videos, and social media content being produced, his point is that content marketers are having to spend an ever-increasing amount of (costly) time and incur more opportunity cost in developing and distributing their content.

Referring specifically to Facebook, for example, he stated that “the exploding amount of content competing for views in users’ news feeds is making it increasingly difficult for brands to get their content delivered organically to their fans.” Certainly Facebook is currently presenting challenges for marketers who want to organically reach their target audiences.

Mark’s is a fair proposition: the sheer amount of content being produced is not all going to get the attention that it once did when, for example, there were fewer blogs competing for readers’ eyeballs.

How to Make Content Marketing Viable

So, what is the solution? I think the secret to success lies in making sure that marketers pay acute attention to their Long Tail, and then use available social tools to engage with their Long Tail audience.

As popularized by Chris Anderson in his best-selling book The Long Tail in 2006-2008, the long tail phenomenon relates directly to this problem of “too much” content; it is a phenomenon of the new online, digital world of ever-increasing information. Rather than a world of scarcity, in which there were limited numbers of TV channels, record companies, radio stations, and newspapers, Anderson stated that “with online distribution … we are entering a world of abundance.”

long-tail-graphAs you can see in this graphical representation of the internet’s long tail (via the Guardian’s Josh Halliday), there are a limited number of products or events that experience “hit status,” as shown at the far left of the graph. Rather, most of the “stuff” being produced – whether music, or Google search terms, or online content – is “niche” material that occupies the never-ending “tail” of the graph as it moves to the right. Each individual item in the long tail is seen by few people, but in the aggregate – as you journey down the tail – this long-tail content is seen by huge numbers of people.

This is exactly where content marketers should be aiming: for their own unique niche within the long tail. It’s a matter of quality over quantity. If they can do this correctly, their content won’t be dead. It will serve its purpose.

Hope for Success: In the Niche

Prior to the maturation of social media networks and tools, hitting these niche markets was more of a challenge. But with the growth and development of social media, in which participants can actively explore and engage with new markets, there is hope yet for success.

This means that marketers can’t fall blindly in love with their content (“My blog post is live! I’m done!”). No, content should be generated with a view to who the audience is. And this means getting out there in social networks, or building up social networks in concert with traditional methods of gathering market information at conferences and industry events, for example. And it means paying attention to the people in those markets via social and traditional channels. Only then will the target markets be interested in viewing your content.

So, I disagree with Mark’s basic premise that “content marketing is not a sustainable strategy.” However, I do agree that it will be more difficult to be successful at content marketing. But in the end, that will just make success all the more rewarding.

Photo credit: Nina Matthews Photography / Foter.com / CC BY

Comments 8

  1. Great points, Nick.

    I definitely see the perception that there’s far too much content going by these days for the average user to find. But I agree that finding a niche — whatever that niche may be — is definitely key to locking in viewers, readers and listeners for your message.

    The alternative, it would seem to me, is to just stay silent and not fight the fight at all, and I’ve yet to figure out how a content producer would truly benefit with that strategy.

    1. Post
      Author
  2. Great post, nick! A well-nitched blog or other content platform actually uses the superabundance to its operators advantage. A loyal follower, once won, will rely on the nitch blog to distill and synthesize the superabundance and add with unique, fresh commentary.

  3. Pingback: MARKET+KULTURE – 5 Ways to Measure Your Social Media ROI

  4. Nick, this is a good article and I agree that finding a TRUE niche market can provide some insulation against Content Shock. However, why do you think aiming content at the “long tail” is a sustainable strategy? Any of your competitors can do the same thing right? The “long tail” is public information. There are no barriers to entry.

    If you do the work to truly carve out a niche market that offers true entry barriers, then you are correct. I actually write about the opportunity of niches and content here: http://www.businessesgrow.com/2014/01/27/best-content-rise-top/

    Thanks for continuing the dialogue.

    1. Post
      Author

      Mark – thanks for your comment and also posting your ‘Against Content Shock” article. I had seen that and meant to read it but other things took over. It’s a great summary of the reactions I suppose you received from your first article. I appreciate that you took the time to assemble all that.

      The “barriers to entry” or “differentiation” issue that you mention is, of course, crucial. This is where it gets really hard. And it’s where the challenge isn’t so much creating and doing “marketing communications” (which a lot of content marketing is) but actually doing real “marketing,” which I’ll define here, off the top of my head, as “not only selling and promoting your product/service to defined markets, but also redefining and reformulating your product/service in response to the market factors you learn while doing your marketing.” So, for example, it might mean 1) changing service offerings, 2) hiring new consultants/professionals to serve the market, 3) offering up service angles that no one else has thought of, and so forth. And that is really hard, as you point out. But that’s real marketing, and it also means that social media/digital marketing can’t just be a mar com fad, but a crucial part of your marketing life.

      Another way to put it is to create a new or unique product/service category. This recent Ad Age article about the art market I think puts it really well. Hope you enjoy it: http://kosar.in/1mehhTI

  5. Pingback: Market+Kulture – The Startup Creator’s Dilemma: Fear and Learning

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *